Welcome to
Sammy’s Hidden Batter

Sammy’s Peanut Butter Luv

Peanut butter chocolate cupcake infused with peanut butter frosting in the center and peanut butter topping, placed with Reese's on the top & a whole Reese's cup.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Sammy’s Crisp & Caramel Duo

A Twix like cupcake is a luxurious dessert, inspired by the classic candy bar. Swirled at the base is chocolate and caramel, filled with a gooey caramel center. Topped with a caramel cream cheese topping, adding both combinations of caramel and chocolate drizzle with a Twix bar placed on top to top it all off.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Sammy’s Caramelized Peanut Swirl

A rich peanut butter, chocolate cupcake, filled with smooth caramel, snickers peanut butter topping, topped with creamy peanut butter frosting, drizzled with caramel and chocolate, finishing with a piece of snickers chocolate candy bar on top.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Sammy’s Candy Cloudburst

With a nostalgic sweetness of cotton candy but placed in the airy form of a pink and blue cupcake. Swirled on top with a choice of two different types of frosting, with or without cream cheese added is swirled color choices of purple and blue frosting. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Oreo Creme and Cookie Crunch

The same idea of an Oreo cookie transformed into a cupcake, the base as a rich chocolate cake, filled & topped with an Oreo cookie frosting, sprinkled with Oreo crumbs, lastly topped with a whole Oreo.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Golden Crunch

Inspired by the very original Butterfinger candy, is the Butterfinger candy into cupcake form. Swirled as the base is both chocolate and peanut butter batter, filled & with a creamy peanut butter frosting swirled in with a hint of Butterfinger pieces, lastly topping it off with a Butterfinger bar on top.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Nutty M&M Delights

Inspired by the very candy itself, peanut butter M&M's, the base with a chocolate & peanut butter combination, filled and topped with peanut butter frosting in the color choices of green, orange, and blue, finishing with a generous amount of peanut butter M&M's to top it off.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Kit Kat Kiss of Wonder’s

Based on the original KitKat candy bar into a cupcake, a chocolate base of a cupcake filled and topped off with a KitKat buttercream frosting, finishing up with half a KitKat Bar on top.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Sour Shockers

Based on the sour patch original candy, is a cupcake of that choice. Typically having a base as light and fluffy, citrus flavored cake base, topped with a cream cheese frosting blend dedicated to the candy itself in multiple colors to choose from rosy, red, electric blue, bright neon green, vivid yellow, hot pink, and citrus orange. Officially topping off the touch with sour patch candy placed on top. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Shamrock Shock

Available limited time edition for St. Patrick's week is Sammy's Shamrock Shock, with flavors similar to sour patch kids, is a variety of blueberry, orange, strawberry, raspberry, and lemon. With an assorted color choices of, red, pink, orange, yellow, and blue to choose from, filled & topped with a cream cheese frosting of that particular sour patch flavor. Decorated with our very own sour patch rainbow, cream cheese clouds, sour patch kids, sprinkled on is our St. Patrick's Day sprinkles, and edible glitter for that final shine to our holidays.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual Yes

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Brownie Fusion Cheesecake

Chocolate brownie base with cream cheese frosting drizzled with chocolate drizzle and cocoa topping.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Choco City of Cream Dream’s

A delectable cupcake that reimagines the original Boston creme donut, The indulgent base consists of a warm, buttery, vanilla blend, filled with a vanilla velvety custard in the middle, topping off with a chocolate frosting on the top. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Macchiato Magic

A decadent cupcake that brings together the rich flavors of caramel and coffee in one item. Featuring a rich coffee & chocolate base, infused with a caramel latte frosting filling. Topped with an espresso & caramel frosting, drizzled with caramel to top it all off. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Whipped Choco-Cream

A soft and fluffy chocolate cupcake topped with smooth, tangy chocolate cream cheese frosting. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Midnight Fudge Obsession

Made with premium dark cocoa, topped & filled with a chocolate cream cheese frosting and a chocolate waffle stick. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added) (Gluten free option does not include chocolate waffle stick)

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Choco-Mint Whirl

A popular menu item, with a chocolate, mint base of a cupcake, filled and topped with a mint, green, frosting, with a Hersey's chocolate to finish topping it off as the final look. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Campfire Cravings

Trying to have the perfect combination of a s'mores treat from the campfire? Try this nostalgic cupcake with a rich chocolate and marshmallow base, filled with a smores filling in the center, topped with a chocolate cream cheese frosting, marshmallow drizzle, chocolate drizzle, graham cracker crumbs, smores spice blend, mini chocolate chips, full graham cracker & Hersey pieces to top it off.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Golden Cocoa bliss

With a base of a deep chocolate cake, filled with homemade, rich caramel in the center, topped off with a caramel cream cheese topping, drizzle in caramel & mini chocolate chips to top it off.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Dough Licious Bites

A twisted combination of two flavors, a chocolate cake base swirled with a chocolate chip cookie dough base, topped with a cookie dough cream cheese topping, topped off with a mini cookie baked on the top.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Nutter Butter Delight

Based on the original cookie itself, Nutter butter, is a rich swirled chocolate & peanut butter base cupcake. Topping off with peanut butter frosting, drizzled in chocolate, garnishing half a Nutter butter bar on top.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual Yes

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Crystal Berry Soda

Based on the light and fluffy, infused with bright, citrusy sweetness of blue raspberry soda for a refreshing twist, topped with a silky blue raspberry cream cheese frosting balancing the perfect combination of tartness & sweetness. Topping off the cupcake with blue sugar crystals and a drizzle of blue raspberry syrup.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Tropical Orange Rush

A cupcake that captures the essence of orange cream soda, with a marshmallow cream cheese filling, topped with marshmallow cream cheese frosting. Topped with orange sprinkles, chewy orange slice gummies, and a dash of edible glitter to the final shine.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Banana Choco-Peanut Cream

Mouthwatering combination of three different flavors in one cupcake, rich chocolate, blend of ripe bananas, and creamy peanut butter. Filled with a chocolate & banana pudding, topped with a creamy blend of the three flavors swirled onto the top of the cupcake is banana, peanut butter and chocolate frosting. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Tripple Treat Temptation

Representing the Neapolitan ice-cream itself is a twisted combination of chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry all in one cupcake, filled & topped off with a chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla cream cheese frosting swirled together.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Swirl Seduction

With two twisted flavors, a combination of vanilla & chocolate base of a cupcake, filled & topped off with a chocolate & vanilla cream cheese frosting swirled together to top off the final treat.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual Yes

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Golden Cinnamon Twist

Just like the original Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal is an inspired version of this cereal right into a cupcake. The base having a soft, cinnamon-spiced cake with hints of brown sugar, cinnamon cream cheese frosting, topping off the rest of the cupcake with sprinkles of Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal,

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Fruity Fiesta Flakes

Based on the original cereal fruity pebbles, is the cupcake form, with a vanilla, fruity pebbles base, generously, mixed with fruity pebbles for a burst of fruity flavor and crunch. Adding a marshmallow cream cheese frosting topping, with multiple options of colors for cupcakes to choose from, including, rosy, pink, soft citrus orange, mint green, periwinkle purple, and sky blue. Lastly topped off with fruity pebbles to enhance the cupcake.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Fudge flake Treats

Based on the original cocoa pebbles cereal itself, is the cupcake version, with the base of a rich cocoa blend of cocoa pebbles to add a crunch, filled with a creamy chocolate pudding, topped with a chocolate cream cheese frosting, with cocoa flakes on top to finish the final product.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Citrus Pink Twist

Inspired by the very drink itself pink lemonade, is a cupcake version of this choice. The base swirled into two flavors of lemon and strawberry batter, topped off with a swirled lemon & strawberry cream cheese frosting, finishing off the rest of the cupcake with a light dash of yellow sprinkles & mini strawberries for extra flavor. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Banana Cream Dream

Scrumptious cupcake that combines a comforting flavor similar to banana bread with a side of banana pudding. With a base of a banana bread cupcake, with a luscious banana pudding filling, lastly, topped is the banana cream cheese frosting, sprinkled graham cracker crumbs & banana slices adding the perfect combination of crunch.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Pink Creme de la Berry

Featuring the base as a light, flavorful strawberry foundation, topped & filled with a strawberry whipped cream cheese frosting, topping off the rest with a crushed graham cracker on top with chopped strawberries.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Sun Kissed Coloda

A tropical delight featuring a moist fruity pineapple flavor, filled with a coconut cream filling, topped with a coconut cream cheese frosting, a pineapple slice, golden edible glitter, and a festive mini umbrella for the perfect island vibe.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Citrus Glow

Based on a zesty citrus lemon base is Sammy's Citrus Glow, filled & topped off with a lemon cream cheese frosting, a dash of edible golden glitter, and a lemon slice for the final touch.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual Yes

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Infused Waffle Wonder

A popular breakfast treat, mimicking a blueberry pancake is Sammy's Infused Waffle Wonder, with the base of a fluffy, butter vanilla, and blueberry cupcake, filled with a blueberry filling, topped with a blueberry cream cheese topping, topped off with blueberries for the final touch.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Sugared Maple Dreams

With a base of a simple maple flavor, top it with a moist creamy maple flavored frosting and finished with a sprinkle of toasted pecans for the perfect balance of sweetness and crunch! (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Vanilla Cream Rainbow Swirl

A soft and fluffy vanilla cupcake topped with smooth, tangy cream cheese frosting, offering a simple yet irresistible flavor combination. (Including a choice of multiple colors of frosting options) & (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $5

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Festive Sprinkles of Fun

With a celebration in every bite, a fluffy, vanilla cake in multiple colors of pink, blue, and purple, studded with colorful sprinkles that bake into vibrant pops of color. Topped off with a smooth, cream cheese, vanilla, buttercream frosting, in swirled colors of blue, pink, and purple, finishing off with a dash of rainbow sprinkles and an added option of silver edible glitter to add to the top to top it all off. (Gluten free options will be another upcharge to the order if added)

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Sweet Cinna-Dream

The ultimate Cinnabon experience in cupcake form, completed with a homemade Cinnabon placed on top drizzled in creamy drizzle & frosting.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Sammy’s Chata Creme Crave

Inspired by the Rum Chatta drink itself is an imitative version of the drink in a cupcake. With a Rum Chatta extract infusing the base of the cupcake, topped with a Rum Chatta Cream Cheese frosting, topping it off with a dash of cinnamon to the final touch.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Stars & Batter

This special limited time edition cupcake features a blend of blueberry and vanilla butter buttercream cream cheese frosting. Crafted in celebration of Presidents Day, this patriotic treat is our sweet tribute to the love we share for our country.

In Stock - ½ dozen + No
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free

Sammy’s Spice & Everything Nice

Based on a basic form of a cinnamon flavor infused into a cupcake, filled and topped with a cinnamon cream cheese frosting, topped off with cinnamon powder.

In Stock - ½ dozen + Yes
In Stock - individual No

1 Dozen: $40 ½ Dozen: $20 Individual: $4

Gluten Free